Menu of Steamboat Wharf Pizza in Nantucket, Massachusetts, USA

Menu Overview

Steamboat Wharf Pizza, nestled at 10 Broad St, Nantucket, offers a genuine taste of New York-style pizza right on the island. As a pizza enthusiast, particularly fond of authentic NYC slices, I found their menu thoughtfully curated, with a special nod to classic simplicity and freshness.

The highlight of the menu is undoubtedly their Pepperoni Slice, a true testament to that iconic thin crust, slightly crisp texture that New Yorkers swear by. The crust strikes a delicate balance—it’s not too thick, yet crisply bites down with just a touch of chewiness, delivering that familiar foldable integrity. The cheese-to-sauce ratio on both their slices and whole pizzas leans toward a satisfying, well-melted blanket of mozzarella that carries the savory tomato notes beautifully.

For those looking for variety, Steamboat Wharf Pizza offers both individual Cheese Pizza Slices starting at $4.70 and daily specials such as 2 slices of cheese pizza for $8.50, catering perfectly to a quick grab-and-go meal or casual dining experience. Whole pizzas come in two sizes—an 18" classic cheese pie priced at $22.50 and a more modest 12" pizza for $12.00—with an array of extra toppings including onion, green pepper, spinach, pineapple, and ranch dressing, each thoughtfully priced per pizza size.

Complementing the pizzas is the Classic Caesar Salad ($8.75), an ideal starter or side that provides a crisp, refreshing counterpoint to the rich, cheesy slices. Paired with their beer selection, the menu promises a well-rounded comfort-food experience that’s simple yet satisfying.

Though some customers note that toppings can feel a bit pricey and occasionally of inconsistent quality—such as the use of canned mushrooms—the overall pizza quality resonates strongly with fans of Brooklyn-style pie. Reviews from locals and visitors alike praise the authenticity of the thin, flavorful crust and the balanced cheese and sauce blend. The slight premium on price appears justified by the genuine flavor profile and location, but could be reconsidered to widen accessibility.

In sum, Steamboat Wharf Pizza captures the spirit of New York’s streets in a charming, no-frills Nantucket setting. Its menu is straightforward but executed with care, offering pizza lovers a reliable spot to satisfy those thin-crust cravings. Whether ordering by the slice or indulging in a whole pie, the experience here conjures that cherished NYC vibe—crisp, cheesy, and unapologetically classic.